Victoria’s Secret fashion show sad commentary on American values

By Timothy Lydon

Published: Monday, December 12, 2011

Updated: Monday, August 27, 2012

Miranda Kerr Victoria's Secret

AP Photo

In this Wednesday, Nov. 9, 2011 photo, supermodel Miranda Kerr walks the runway during theVictoria's Secret fashion show in New York. Kerr is wearing The Fantasy Treasure Bra, designed by London Jewelers and valued at $2.5 million. It's not just the push-up bras or feathered wings that give some topVictoria's Secret models their sexy swagger: It's their off-the-catwalk lives as mothers, they say, that give them their confidence and signature curves.

The Victoria's Secret Fashion show has become an American event, neatly packaged and marketed with a primetime network slot. The commercials, featuring tall, leggy, semi-emaciated women, accompanied by whatever musicians happen to be popular at the time, are no different from the advertisements we are fed for professional sports, action movies, and sitcoms – quick hits, quick jokes, and carnal images of women.

Simply put, Victoria's Secret buys airtime once a year to remind America that their definition of beauty still holds reign.

However, most women in this country (and the world) do not look or dress like these fashion models. It wouldn't have been inappropriate for these models to hold up a "We are the 1%" sign. By outfitting size two women with long, straight hair Victoria's Secret just perpetuates the narrow, racist standard of beauty in our society. Where are the dark skinned women? Where are the size eights? Where are the women with strong hands and forearms from working manual labor jobs each day? We adulate women who have no merits beyond their looks. That is why our society is spiritually bankrupt.

The show brings the world of low-brow fashion to the masses for one night a year. Anna Wintour was not in the front row and Tori Burch did not unveil a new line of handbags. This was not art, it was crass: women wearing sparkly underwear and campy angel wings. What demographic did CBS think this would appeal to? Men ages 18 to 40? If so, they had a lot in common with the mostly white, middle aged women in the audience. I would have liked to know Kanye West's thoughts as he looked out onto the crowd to see these women so clearly unsure of what to do with the rap music that he was spewing.

"Let me introduce my big brother to give you the new shit," West said - parodying his best rap artist -as he introduced Jay-Z. I am sure performing for this demographic was exactly why Jay-Z and Kanye got into music in the first place. How rewarding it must have been to see all those people in the crowd who could really relate to what they were saying.

The show should be mocked, as should the rap duo. Just produce a catchy beat and you will be paid for your services anywhere. They are simply entertainers, in the same category as the CBS renegade Charlie Sheen – get in, get out, get the dough and don't think about what you are really saying and who you are saying it to.

What real artists would take part in this corporate funded, network executive wet dream? The self-proclaimed kings of rap must have cashed in. Money over integrity – listen to their music, they will tell you the same thing.

Comments

3 comments
Timothy Lydon
Thu Dec 15 2011 21:40
To call me a racist is banal, and to do it as "anonymous" is cowardly. I am arguing for a new, or equal, representation of "beauty" in mass media - against the pervasive idealized images of white women with straight hair. To do this, I call on anyone with the power and influence to act to do so. Those with a "post-racial," "post-Obama" perspective on race will say that the ideal is to be color blind; they argue that race is behind us and not an issue we have to worry about any longer. This is easy for white people to say because their idealized image is still prominent, but put yourself in the shoes of a young black woman as she watched the Victoria's Secret Fashion show. She can't help but notice the conspicuous absence of girls with dark skin and afro-textured hair. This is corrosive.

I am critical of Jay-Z and Kanye for taking part in such a senseless event; and for the fact that they took money from a corporation that every year just perpetuates a discriminatory definition of beauty - a definition that happens to exclude women of their color. These men have the power and influence to help fight the gender and racial stereotypes that exist in our culture; instead, they played to them; strengthened them, and reinforced them. If this observation makes me a racist, then so be it, I am willing to live with that title.

SophiaBob
Tue Dec 13 2011 14:25
I agree with most of what you said. But I'd like to know what artists you consider "real artists"?
Anonymous
Tue Dec 13 2011 12:25
U are one bitter, uncultured, racist, programmed scum bag............... Hmmmm, what demographic do u write for a-hole?
View full site